Post by Karen on Nov 18, 2018 14:12:41 GMT -6
SPOILERS AHEAD!
OK people, I've seen it and am not too sure what I think.
Anyone what to comment?
Thoughts about what the "big reveal" is?
McGonagall? Did she "fit" ? Seemed like an after thought..."hey let's throw McGonagall in there, see if people are paying attention?"
I don't know, I need to get my thoughts together here...
Was incredibly ticked that the story line really didn't seem to move on much at all. And I get the feeling that they are milking this for all it's worth. And that's probably somewhere around a gazillion dollars by the time the series is finished.
SO GLAD that she didn't opt for a cheap plot device by placing him on the sinking Titanic!! I was saying a little prayer. "please please don't have this be the Titanic." And it wasn't. That really would've cheezed me off.
Adding this too, I thought Johnny did his usual great job, sadly he wasn't in the movie as much as I'd hoped, and I'm not vested in the storyline of the others, Queenie, Tina, etc., so that may be part of my issue with the film?
Editing again to say that I'm having a hard time, I didn't LOVE the film, but I didn't HATE it either. It has great moments and as always Johnny was stellar. I think I was hugely disappointed that he wasn't front and center more of the time. He is the title character. I will go see it again, probably this weekend and try to go to a later showing, with more people in the theater. I saw it before 10am. More from me...
OK people, I've seen it and am not too sure what I think.
Anyone what to comment?
Thoughts about what the "big reveal" is?
McGonagall? Did she "fit" ? Seemed like an after thought..."hey let's throw McGonagall in there, see if people are paying attention?"
I don't know, I need to get my thoughts together here...
Was incredibly ticked that the story line really didn't seem to move on much at all. And I get the feeling that they are milking this for all it's worth. And that's probably somewhere around a gazillion dollars by the time the series is finished.
SO GLAD that she didn't opt for a cheap plot device by placing him on the sinking Titanic!! I was saying a little prayer. "please please don't have this be the Titanic." And it wasn't. That really would've cheezed me off.
Adding this too, I thought Johnny did his usual great job, sadly he wasn't in the movie as much as I'd hoped, and I'm not vested in the storyline of the others, Queenie, Tina, etc., so that may be part of my issue with the film?
Editing again to say that I'm having a hard time, I didn't LOVE the film, but I didn't HATE it either. It has great moments and as always Johnny was stellar. I think I was hugely disappointed that he wasn't front and center more of the time. He is the title character. I will go see it again, probably this weekend and try to go to a later showing, with more people in the theater. I saw it before 10am. More from me...
